From the archive...
I’ve read Mark Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
at least twice, and possibly three times—I’m honestly not certain. I may very
well read it again one of these days because it’s a favorite—and because I
recently read Jon Clinch’s “prequel” titled Finn, which imagines
the life of Huck’s father, whom Huck referred to as “Pap.”
Known only as Finn, the titular figure is the black sheep of
his family. His father is one James Manchester Finn, known throughout as “the
Judge,” a man whose “own father before him had been a drunk just like his son.
The one he hated for it and the other he pities but not enough. Drink he
understands, the Judge tells himself, because it is a thing of vast and nearly
indomitable power—like the law, like the wilderness, like history itself.”
Among other things, this dark and sometimes brutal novel
recounts Finn’s days catching fish which he sells to local merchants and tavern
owners in exchange for goods and whisky. More importantly, it recounts his
conflicts with his family and some of those merchants, how it came about that
Huck was born—and to whom—and how and why Finn spent a year in prison. The
reader is also shown moments in the lives of other key characters, some from
Twain’s novel, most created for this one.
When I discovered the existence of Finn, I bought a copy
because the premise was intriguing. Unfortunately—from my point of view, at
least—the execution left a great deal to be desired. The use of the omniscient
viewpoint severely diluted characterizations, the author too often telling what
characters were thinking and/or feeling, or what they might be thinking and/or
feeling, rather than more convincingly showing them in action.
I read the Kindle edition, so I don’t know if what I’m about
to fault also occurs in the hardcover or paperback versions. In any event,
sentences in dialogues which are questions often but not always end with
periods rather than question marks. Clinch also shuns em dashes or ellipses in
favor of periods in lines which tail off or are interrupted. If this occurs in
the physical editions as well, I can only attribute it to a feeble and annoying
attempt at artiness. There are also many instances of commas omitted with
apparent deliberateness, which I found equally annoying.
If you take a look at Amazon’s page for the hardcover
edition, you’ll find, just beneath the boxes indicating what editions are
available, blurbs and excerpts from other authors as well as from reviews in
some major newspapers, all praising Finn as a major literary achievement. “A triumph of successful plotting, convincing
characterization and lyrical prose,” declares the Rocky Mountain News. While
I’ll concede that there are some beautifully written prose passages throughout,
I also think that there are far too many instances of word-drunkenness,
self-consciousness—that Clinch got carried away such that in many passages you
can practically hear him bellowing, “I’m writing!” Some of that writing struck
me as pretentious.
Several times early into the book, I seriously debated about whether to keep going or quit. I was intrigued just enough to keep going—obviously. But based on that hesitancy, I recommend that prospective readers sample the book before purchasing or borrowing it from libraries. Finn was Jon Clinch’s debut novel. It does not compel me to seek out those which have come afterward.
Barry Ergang © 2017, 2023
Among his other works,
Derringer Award-winner Barry Ergang’s locked-room novelette, The Play of Light and Shadow, can be found in e-book formats at Smashwords.com and Amazon.com
No comments:
Post a Comment