Lesa's Book Critiques: KEVIN’S CORNER ANNEX – POSTHUMOUS CHILD BY ROZLAN MOHD NOOR
Friday, December 15, 2023
Tuesday, November 28, 2023
Review: Posthumous Child: Inspector Mislan and The Playground Murder by Rozlan Mohd Noor
Posthumous Child:
Inspector Mislan and The Playground Murder by
Rozlan Mohd Noor is the latest in a good series of police procedurals set in
and around Kuala Lumper, Malaysia. This sixth book in the series is a slower
read than the previous books though the second half of the book picks up
considerably.
As always, Detective Sergeant Johan Kamaruddin
and Inspector Mislan Latiff work a number of cases over the course of the book.
Some are solved fairly quickly. One takes longer and serves as the main case of
the book.
Such is the case here where the main case regards
the discovery of the body of a woman is found in a park in a wealthy area. In
the park there is a large playground setup for both adults and children. In the
children’s area, near a slide, there is the body of a woman. She is dressed and
curled up in a fetal position and clearly dumped at the park.
It is only later during the postmortem that Detective
Sergeant Johan Kamaruddin and Inspector Mislan Latiff learn that the woman was
pregnant. That fact was not obvious on scene. Somebody, presumably, the killer,
took the baby out of her. Who killed the woman, why, and what happened to the
baby drive the case and thus the primary storyline of the book. Those answers
are dark as is most of the book.
This is not a light read, not that any in this
series are, but the tone of this one is darker than most. Inspector Mislan is
also personally going through some things. The pandemic also still has a tight
grip on normal life. As the book moves forward, Inspector Mislan is struck
again and again how people will do horrible things to each other under the
guise of faith or politics. The world is frequently a sick place and Mislan is
increasingly more aware of that fact more than most.
A slow moving and very complicated police
procedural, Posthumous Child: Inspector Mislan and The Playground Murder
by Rozlan Mohd Noor is not my favorite of the series by a long shot. I found
stretches of it slow and tedious until significant progress is eventually made
on the primary case. Of course, that could easily be the mindset of this reader
and not remotely the fault of the author. This time of year is hard for me and
I am well aware that my mood definitely bleeds over into my reading.
While one could start here, I would recommend
starting with the first book, 21
Immortals: Inspector Mislan and the Yee Sang Murders, and working forward. Each book has the core characters evolving
and going through various things that provide nuance and depth to Inspector
Mislan and others. There is a reason why the good Inspector is the way he is these
days. To pick up on everything in the latest read, one really needs to have
read the previous books.
My reading copy was in digital format and a purchase from Amazon as the Dallas Library system does not have this one and staff refused to pick it up when I requested it months ago.
Kevin R. Tipple ©2023
(Begin Here)
Tuesday, March 07, 2023
Review: Philanthropists: Inspector Mislan and the Executioners by Rozlan Mohd Noor
Philanthropists:
Inspector Mislan and the Executioners
by
Rozlan Mohd Noor begins in early 2020 as Covid is just beginning to become a worldwide
threat. In these early days just before lockdowns and societal disruptions, Inspector
Mislan Abdul Latif of the Office of Special Investigations (D9) biggest issue
is trying to deal with the fact that his young son is living with his ex-wife
and he is still haunted by being shot a few months ago. While he would never
admit it, he is lonely and the job is pretty much all he has in his life
outside of the occasional call to his son. He thinks he has everything under
control and nobody sees his loneliness. He thinks that nobody notices how there
is a second or two of hesitation when he enters a crime scene and smells the
spilled blood.
He would be wrong.
His assistant, Detective Sergeant Johan
Kamaruddin certainly notices and did once again at their latest call out. Summoned
to the scene of a double murder by Inspector Shahira Adanan, they arrived at just
after 2:30 in the morning at a two-story house located across the city from their
office. The last house on a dead-end road in a quiet neighborhood. At least,
the neighborhood was quiet, until flooded by a horde of police vehicles with
their flashing lights and chattering radios.
The home is sparsely furnished which leads
Inspector Mislan Latif to believe that it is a rental. In the master bedroom there
are two dead men lying on their side in bed facing each other. Each man has
been shot twice. Once in the back and once in the back of the head. Both are
shirtless.
While their wallets and other
identification is missing, they were found with several different packages of
various drugs stacked on the bed between them.
No sign of their phones, electronic devices, mail or paperwork of any
kind, or anything else that would identify them. All investigators have at this
point are two very dead bodies and a pile of drugs.
Who they are is the first of many
questions Inspector Mislan Latif and his team have to answer in the Philanthropists:
Inspector Mislan and the Executioners. Things get
complicated quickly as getting answers gets more and more difficult due to whom
the victims were and the rapidly escalating threat of Covid.
A significant portion of the read is
devoted to Inspector Mislan’s recollections of events in the various previous
books. Especially the events of the last book, Soulless: Inspector Mislanand the Faceless Girl, which led to his being critically injured. If
you have not read the proceeding books, it would be best to read them in order
starting with 21 Immortals: Inspector Mislan and the Yee Sang Murders
before you embark on this very good read.
My reading copy was a digital arc via NetGalley. Publication date is currently scheduled for March 7th.
Kevin R. Tipple ©2023
Thursday, February 16, 2023
Review: Philanthropists: Inspector Mislan and the Executioners by Rozlan Mohd Noor
Philanthropists:
Inspector Mislan and the Executioners
by
Rozlan Mohd Noor begins in early 2020 as Covid is just beginning to become a worldwide
threat. In these early days just before lockdowns and societal disruptions, Inspector
Mislan Abdul Latif of the Office of Special Investigations (D9) biggest issue
is trying to deal with the fact that his young son is living with his ex-wife
and he is still haunted by being shot a few months ago. While he would never
admit it, he is lonely and the job is pretty much all he has in his life
outside of the occasional call to his son. He thinks he has everything under
control and nobody sees his loneliness. He thinks that nobody notices how there
is a second or two of hesitation when he enters a crime scene and smells the
spilled blood.
He would be wrong.
His assistant, Detective Sergeant Johan
Kamaruddin certainly notices and did once again at their latest call out. Summoned
to the scene of a double murder by Inspector Shahira Adanan, they arrived at just
after 2:30 in the morning at a two-story house located across the city from their
office. The last house on a dead-end road in a quiet neighborhood. At least,
the neighborhood was quiet, until flooded by a horde of police vehicles with
their flashing lights and chattering radios.
The home is sparsely furnished which leads
Inspector Mislan Latif to believe that it is a rental. In the master bedroom there
are two dead men lying on their side in bed facing each other. Each man has
been shot twice. Once in the back and once in the back of the head. Both are
shirtless.
While their wallets and other
identification is missing, they were found with several different packages of
various drugs stacked on the bed between them.
No sign of their phones, electronic devices, mail or paperwork of any
kind, or anything else that would identify them. All investigators have at this
point are two very dead bodies and a pile of drugs.
Who they are is the first of many
questions Inspector Mislan Latif and his team have to answer in the Philanthropists:
Inspector Mislan and the Executioners. Things get
complicated quickly as getting answers gets more and more difficult due to whom
the victims were and the rapidly escalating threat of Covid.
A significant portion of the read is devoted to Inspector Mislan’s recollections of events in the various previous books. Especially the events of the last book, Soulless: Inspector Mislanand the Faceless Girl, which led to his being critically injured. If you have not read the proceeding books, it would be best to read them in order starting with 21 Immortals: Inspector Mislan and the Yee Sang Murders before you embark on this very good read.
My reading copy was a digital arc via NetGalley. Publication date is currently scheduled for March 7th.
Kevin R. Tipple ©2023
Tuesday, July 05, 2022
Review: Soulless: Inspector Mislan And The Faceless Girl by Rozlan Mohd Noor
While I reviewed this book back in April
because of being able to get the read via NetGalley, today is publication day
so I am reminding you of the book today.
Soulless: Inspector Mislan And
The Faceless Girl
by Rozlan Mohd Noor begins at 4 AM in the Jalan Alor area of Kuala Lumpur,
Malaysia. Every city has such an area. A place for sin whether it be drugs,
gambling, or prostitution. Jalen Alor is publicly famous for a certain seafood
restaurant and being an entertainment district. But, other things go on there,
and that includes the dumping of a dead body.
The local police on the beat get
involved because of altercation between a panicked homeless man and a pimp who
was highly offended that his car was jostled by the homeless man. There was
good reason for his panic. In hid drug addled state, he thought the bag was
tossed from god above and was full of money. Instead, he found a body that has
no face. Not that the lack of face stops the rats from coning for a feast now
that the four-legged vermin in the ally can get to it.
When the crime scene forensic team
arrives, it takes some doing to get the rats to back off. They have already done
some damage to the body, but are not responsible for the fact there is no face.
Acid did that and was also responsible for what little is left of her fingers.
The situation means Inspector Mislan Latif and Detective Sergeant Johan
Kamaruddin of Special Investigations (D9) are summoned to the scene to take
over the case.
With no facial identification or
fingerprint identification possible, it is clear that the killer or killers
went to extraordinary efforts to hide the identity of the victim. The
investigators know she was female and probably young and in her late teens or
early twenties. It is also clear that she was tortured before death. The only
clues to her identity are two tattoos. One of which is a butterfly and the
other is some sort of quote or saying.
Those tattoos are a start for Inspector
Mislan in a case that will take him and Johan to various places in Thailand and
back to Malaysia. As always in this series, politics, the interference or
threat of interference by the rich and the powerful, are involved as are the
social dynamics of culture and class across ethnic lines in Malaysian society.
Author Rozlan Mohd Noor paints a rich tapestry of sight and sound in this
series and does so again in Soulless: Inspector Mislan And The Faceless
Girl.
This is the fourth book in the series
and the first one I have read that seemed off at times. I don’t know if it was
my lack of culture awareness or something else, but it seemed strange to have
so many people smiling or amused at incredibly dark and somber moments in the
book. A character will make a response to a dark bit of dialogue or scene
description and be referred to as “smiling” or “laughing” with their dialogue
response. That happened throughout the read and was jarring as it almost always
felt very off in relation to the context of the situation. This issue is
something I never noticed in previous books.
While overall this was an enjoyable
read, it was also marred by a horrible open ending in the final paragraph. An
event abruptly happens at the very end of the book, in the final three sentence
paragraph, and one is left totally hanging. I don’t know if this was deliberate
act by the author, a publisher decision, or what, but it was a very
unsatisfactory end for this reader.
Soulless: Inspector Mislan And
The Faceless Girl
by Rozlan Mohd Noor is a good read. This reader did not find it at the same
level of the previous books in the series, but it was still a good read with
the caveats above. The book is currently scheduled to be released in July 2022.
The previous
books in the series and my reviews:
21 Immortals:
Inspector Mislan and the Yee Sang Murders (June 2021)
DUKE: Inspector
Mislan and The Expressway Murders (August 2021)
UTube: Inspector Mislan and the Emancipatist Conspiracy (October 2021)
My reading copy was a digital arc via NetGalley.
Kevin R. Tipple ©2022
Thursday, April 07, 2022
Review: Soulless: Inspector Mislan And The Faceless Girl by Rozlan Mohd Noor
Soulless: Inspector Mislan And
The Faceless Girl
by Rozlan Mohd Noor begins at 4 AM in the Jalan Alor area of Kuala Lumpur,
Malaysia. Every city has such an area. A place for sin whether it be drugs,
gambling, or prostitution. Jalen Alor is publicly famous for a certain seafood
restaurant and being an entertainment district. But, other things go on there,
and that includes the dumping of a dead body.
The local police on the beat get
involved because of altercation between a panicked homeless man and a pimp who
was highly offended that his car was jostled by the homeless man. There was
good reason for his panic. In hid drug addled state, he thought the bag was
tossed from god above and was full of money. Instead, he found a body that has
no face. Not that the lack of face stops the rats from coning for a feast now
that the four-legged vermin in the ally can get to it.
When the crime scene forensic team
arrives, it takes some doing to get the rats to back off. They have already done
some damage to the body, but are not responsible for the fact there is no face.
Acid did that and was also responsible for what little is left of her fingers. The
situation means Inspector Mislan Latif and Detective Sergeant Johan Kamaruddin
of Special Investigations (D9) are summoned to the scene to take over the case.
With no facial identification or
fingerprint identification possible, it is clear that the killer or killers
went to extraordinary efforts to hide the identity of the victim. The
investigators know she was female and probably young and in her late teens or
early twenties. It is also clear that she was tortured before death. The only
clues to her identity are two tattoos. One of which is a butterfly and the
other is some sort of quote or saying.
This is the fourth book in the series
and the first one I have read that seemed off at times. I don’t know if it was
my lack of culture awareness or something else, but it seemed strange to have
so many people smiling or amused at incredibly dark and somber moments in the
book. A character will make a response to a dark bit of dialogue or scene
description and be referred to as “smiling” or “laughing” with their dialogue
response. That happened throughout the read and was jarring as it almost always
felt very off in relation to the context of the situation. This issue is
something I never noticed in previous books.
While overall this was an enjoyable
read, it was also marred by a horrible open ending in the final paragraph. An
event abruptly happens at the very end of the book, in the final three sentence
paragraph, and one is left totally hanging. I don’t know if this was deliberate
act by the author, a publisher decision, or what, but it was a very
unsatisfactory end for this read.
Soulless: Inspector Mislan And
The Faceless Girl
by Rozlan Mohd Noor is a good read. This reader did not find it at the same
level of the previous books in the series, but it was still a good read with
the caveats above. The book is currently scheduled to be released in July 2022.
The previous
books in the series and my reviews:
21
Immortals: Inspector Mislan and the Yee Sang Murders (June 2021)
DUKE:
Inspector Mislan and The Expressway Murders (August 2021)
UTube: Inspector Mislan and the Emancipatist Conspiracy (October 2021)
My reading copy was a digital arc via
net galley.
Kevin R. Tipple ©2022
Tuesday, February 22, 2022
Lesa's Book Critiques: KEVIN’S CORNER ANNEX – DUKE BY ROZLAN MOHD NOOR
Tuesday, October 26, 2021
Review: UTube: Inspector Mislan and the Emancipatist Conspiracy by Rozlan Mohd Noor
UTube: Inspector
Mislan and the Emancipatist Conspiracy by Rozlan Mohd Noor is the third
read in the police procedural series based in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Inspector
Mislan and Detective Sergeant Johan are brought into an ongoing case when a friend
of a sexual assault victim dies.
That is the second
attack in a case that starts when Era Amilia was sexually assaulted. The attack
was video recorded and shared on the internet via UTUBE. Hours later, she died
after a fall the balcony of her ninth-floor apartment at the condo tower. Was
she pushed or did she jump? While The
sexual child abuse investigation division intended to handle that case by
themselves as it was tied into the rape case, when a second rape attack results
in an obvious murder of a friend of the victim, Special Investigations is brought
in and that means Inspector Mislan and Detective Sergeant Johan.
That means the
independent take charge MIslan is forced to work with Inspector Sherry and her
squad. Not only does he have to work with her, the powers that be have decreed
he has to take orders from her. Mislan’s reputation is known to all and with
the intense media focus and political factors, he is not going to be in charge.
Inspector Sherry She is very much by the book and Mislan isn’t. She also is not
going to jeopardize her career by letting Mislan have his usual free reign.
With pressure
mounting and additional attacks and recordings being posted online, the chase
is on to stop at least two, if not more, rapists who believe they are
correcting wayward behavior. Things are very complicated and the case has many
angles to pursue as the officers involved try to find a way to work together.
This is the third
in the series that began with 21
Immortals: Inspector Mislan and the Yee Sang Murders and DUKE: Inspector Mislan and The
Expressway Murders.
Personal details of the lives of Inspector Mislan and several others away from
the job continue here in various established secondary storylines. Therefore, it
is best to read these books in order as previous case are mentioned along with
continuing secondary storylines.
As always in
this series, things are very complicated. UTube: Inspector Mislan and the
Emancipatist Conspiracy is one of those books there is hard to explain
in greater detail without ruining the read. Suffice it to say, these police
procedurals are complicated and solidly good reads with interesting cases and
plenty of detail on sights and sounds that the reader feels like they are there
working the case and eating the food. As in earlier books, there is a lot of
mention of food so be prepared.
UTube: Inspector
Mislan and the Emancipatist Conspiracy
Rozlan Mohd Noor
Arcade CrimeWise
July 2021
ISBN# 978-1950691425
Hardback (also
available in eBook format)
336 Pages
My copy came via
the Martin Luther King JR Branch of the Dallas Public Library System.
Kevin R. Tipple
©2021
Tuesday, September 21, 2021
Bookblog of the Bristol Library: DUKE: Inspector Mislan and The Expressway Murders by Rozlan Mohd Noor
Thursday, August 12, 2021
Review: DUKE: Inspector Mislan and The Expressway Murders by Rozlan Mohd Noor
DUKE:
Inspector Mislan and The Expressway Murders by Rozlan Mohd Noor is the second in the
series that began with 21 Immortals: Inspector Mislan and the Yee SangMurders. This book is also set during a holiday. In this case, it is about
to be the Eid or the Hari Raya holiday at the end of Ramadan.
A crash on the DUKE
Expressway is never helpful and certainly not now during the holiday period. A
black Mercedes E200 crashed and a quick glance in the car indicates that a man
and a woman are both dead by the amount of blood on their bodies. It soon
becomes clear that they died by gunshots. Because the two deceased individuals
were both powerful business people with serious connections, it is not long
before the Special Investigations Unit, formerly known as Major Crimes, is
brought into the case.
That means Inspector
Mislan Latif and detective Sergeant Johan Kamarudin are on the case. From the first
glance into the car, Inspector Mislan thinks that the deaths of sixty-year-old
Mahadi Mokshin and thirty-four-year-old Zaleha Jalani, are far more complicated
than a simple murder-suicide. The way the car crashed, the way the figures are
in the car, and other aspects of the scene become critical pieces of evidence
to Inspector Mislan that lead to his growing belief that there was a third
person, the actual shooter, in the car.
The problem is
that he has to not only prove there was a third person in the car, he also has
to prove the identity of that person. As the pressure from the media and the
police bureaucracy mount to close the case as a lover’s triangle gone wrong
that led to a murder-suicide, it becomes clear that there are many powerful
forces working against his and his team’s efforts to get to the bottom of what happened
in that car and why. Things get complicated quickly when the rich and
powerfully connected start exerting their influence upon all involved.
Once again, author Rozlan Mohd Noor brings the sights, sounds, and culture of Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, to life in this second book of the series. Along with the rich detailed setting of a land far away from American readers, the author details a police investigation that could just easily happen here in any city. Those who are connected to a crime and have the means to exert their influence, almost always try to insulate themselves from the investigation and the public scrutiny. It is a universal human condition and one that speaks across societal as well as cultural divides.
Greed,
corruption, money and the power of politics to shape a certain result is a universal
problem familiar to readers everywhere. DUKE: Inspector Mislan and the
Expressway Murders by Rozlan Mohd Noor is a solidly good police procedural
well worth your time.
The third book
in the series, UTube: Inspector Mislan and the Emancipatist Conspiracy,
is now out and on order at the Dallas Public Library System. I have a hold on a
copy when they get it in.
DUKE: Inspector
Mislan and The Expressway Murders
Rozlan Mohd Noor
Arcade CrimeWise
https://www.skyhorsepublishing.com/arcade-publishing/
March 2021
ISBN#
978-1-950691-41-8
Hardback (also
available in eBook format)
336 Pages
My copy came via the Martin Luther King JR Branch of the Dallas Public Library System.
Kevin R. Tipple
©2021








