Review: Return to Sender: A Longmire Mystery by Craig Johnson

As a reader, I am very tired of the whole cult trope. You know the drill. Shady charismatic cult leader, a couple of enforcers, and a bunch of cult church members drugged out of their minds, following the leader who hears/sees God, scriptures in the sand, whatever, and bad things inevitably happen. Unfortunately, that is the majority of the story in Return to Sender: A Longmire Mystery by Craig Johnson.

 

As the publisher, Viking, has a long history of ignoring my ARC requests on NetGalley, which then counts as a denial against me in their system, I knew it would happen again this time. So, as soon as it was listed in the Dallas Public Library System, I requested it, and was prepared to wait a very long time. This book, apparently, does not have the interest level as his previous books have had, as it came very quickly. While I was on the list for print and digital, the digital arrived first. It did so just three weeks after publication and less than two weeks after they actually had the copy in the system. That never happens.  

 

The latest in the series has Sheriff Walt Longmire far from home and in the area of what is known as the “Red Desert.” Located in the Southern central part of Wyoming, the region features a massive sand dune formation and a lot of strange happenings.

 

At the behest of Mike Thurman, a cousin of Walt Longmire’s late wife, he is there to find a missing woman. Blair McGowan has gone missing. She had been a multi-year contractor for the United States Postal Service and had a route that went over 307 miles. That distance made the very isolated carrier route the longest in the country. She just vanished one day and nobody knows where she is or what happened.

 

Her 68 International Travelall rolled out from the parking lot at the post office one morning and she was in it. Many hours later, it was parked back in the lot. While she was not seen exiting the car, she seemingly did her route, and then just walked away. She was known to be a bit stubborn and eccentric so it could have happened that way. But, Mike does not think so at all.

 

After a short period of time, her scummy boyfriend sold it at to a local used car dealership. That car is still there and available for sale. The boyfriend also quickly sold off the rest of her stuff. He’s clearly moved on and is in no way concerned or caring about what happened.

 

Walt Longmire knows the local law enforcement and can’t really find any fault with their investigation. They had next to nothing to go on and worked the deal as best as they could. They also don’t seem inclined to put any more work into the case. Which is why Mike reached out to Walt.

 

Mike wants Walt to go undercover as a postal contractor, take over her route, drive and deliver mail, ask questions, and see if he can figure out why she went missing and what happened.

 

He agrees, buys her car, and before long is out on the route delivering the mail. Of course, things get weird as this is the Red Desert, aka, the Bermuda Triangle with Sand. And, if you have read the book description, you know that part of the weird is the aforementioned cult trope. No spoilers here.

 

Despite the fact that it leans heavily on the cult trope, Return to Sender: A Longmire Mystery is a good read. Predictable in many places, the book moves quickly and tells a good yarn. Which is about all you can ask for living in a time when cults are all the rage.

 

Amazon Associate Purchase Link: https://amzn.to/4lrXYpF

 

My reading copy came in eBook form from the Dallas Public Library System.

  

Kevin R. Tipple ©2025