Monday, December 22, 2025

Aubrey Nye Hamilton Reviews: A Case of Mice and Murder: The Trials of Gabriel Ward by Sally Smith

 .

Of Mice and Murder (Raven Books, June 2025) has been getting raves from readers of historical mysteries since it was released. Now it is popping up on favorites of the year lists and I was determined to see what the buzz was about.

It is, as everyone says, a wonderful story. Set in May 1901, the quirky Sir Gabriel Ward KC, an outstanding addition to the pantheon of amateur sleuths, literally stumbles across the body of Lord Norman Dunning, Lord Chief Justice of England, as Ward was attempting to enter his legal office in the Inner Temple. Dunning was in popular opinion amazingly average and the last person to be murdered. But here he was, expired and not of natural causes.

By law the Temple is not part of the City of London and London police are not allowed to enter without invitation. The author goes into some detail about the history of the Temple and provides a helpful map. To keep the police at bay for a few days, Ward was given the task of investigating the death accompanied by a police constable to take notes. Ward was on the verge of an important piece of litigation that needed his full attention and he did not welcome this new and strange assignment. Indeed, he did not welcome anything that disrupted his long-established routine. His outstanding intellect was recognized by his colleagues however and it was felt if anyone could find an answer to this peculiar event, it would be Sir Gabriel.

The second plot thread is just as perplexing. Years ago, legal publisher Herbert Moore found a manuscript for a children’s book with no letter or explanation on his doorstep. He examined it briefly and discarded it in the nearest bin, from which his young daughter retrieved it and read it, enthralled. Moore decided to publish it as a Christmas one-off and found himself with a runaway bestseller. He had made some inquiries as to the author that came up empty and despite some reservations continued to publish the book. Now a young woman has come forward claiming authorship of the book and Moore hasn’t a legal leg to stand on. In desperation he has turned to Ward for help.

Sally Smith spent all her working life as a barrister and later King's Counsel in the Inner Temple. Her deep knowledge of the history of the Temple and understanding of its operations give the story a commanding sense of authenticity. The references to new-fangled forensic tools such as fingerprints and the mentions of the limitations placed on women’s lives sets the context equally well. Those same limitations offer clues to the resolution. The dual mystery itself is nicely constructed, and Sir Gabriel is a vivid personality with whom I can easily identify.

Fortunately for us all, there is no need to wait for the second book in the series; it is available for purchase now. Library Journal starred review. Highly recommended.

 


·         Publisher: ‎Raven Books

·         Publication date: ‎June 17, 2025

·         Language: ‎English

·         Print length: ‎336 pages

·         ISBN-10: ‎1639736921

·         ISBN-13: ‎978-1639736928



Amazon Associate Purchase Link:  https://amzn.to/3MIybxm

 

  

Aubrey Nye Hamilton ©2025 

Aubrey Hamilton is a former librarian who works on Federal It projects by day and reads mysteries at night.

No comments: