Sunday, August 09, 2026

Review: Death at a Scottish Halloween: A Scottish Isle Mystery by Lucy Connelly


This comes out Tuesday....


As I noted long ago when I reviewed the first book of this series, An American in Scotland: A Scottish Isle Mystery by Lucy Connelly, I am not a cozy mystery kind of guy. I lean more towards police procedurals as well as grittier mystery and crime fiction. But, I enjoyed that first book quite a lot and have enjoyed every read since. That includes the latest book, fifth in the series, Death at a Scottish Halloween: A Scottish Isle Mystery.

 

Dr. Emilia McRoy left it all behind to move to Sea Isle, Scotland, and she could not be happier. As the book begins, she is working on her room in an extensive haunted house. Halloween, or as the locals refer to it, All Hallows Eve, is a big deal. Doctor McRoy missed it last year due to attending a wedding so her and her assistant, Abigail, are going all out to create the spookiest doctor’s office ever. Their room is one of several that people will walk through and experience scares a plenty.

 

It is a fun evening until, after nearly everyone has left, they discover a body in the room across the hall from their own. Not only is Duncan, a man they just met a few hours earlier, dead, a butcher knife is planted in his chest. The same butcher knife that Dr. Emilia McRoy had brought from home and was using as a prop in their horror scene. With all the people that came through and the loud commotion these past hours, neither the good doctor nor Abigail noticed who took it or when it went missing. But, it is definitely is now planted in the dead man’s chest. Probably right through his heart.

 

Despite the fact it was her knife that is the murder weapon, and their multi hour close proximity to the victim, they are never considered as suspects by Constable Ewan or the other locals. Instead, as part of their jobs, they handle this situation as they have before with other murders and get to work with the removal of the body, the autopsy, and the investigation of the crime.

 

So, if they did not do it, then who did?

 

That is the question that Constable Ewan and his team, along with the good doctor and Abigail must answer. A second murder soon happens and that ratchets up the pressure. At the same time, other things are going on and the good doctor is getting threats and more.

 

The latest in the series is another good read. I recommend reading the series in order from the beginning as significant character development has happened over the course of the series and relationships have changed and evolved. Those who are fans of Halloween, or All Hallows Eve, will get far more out of this read than those of us who don’t care for any of it at all.

 

A very good read in a very good cozy mystery series, Death at a Scottish Halloween: A Scottish Isle Mystery by Lucy Connelly is well worth your time.

 


Amazon Associate Purchase Link: https://amzn.to/4eFU5wu 

 

Entire Series Amazon Associate Purchase Link: https://amzn.to/4uA7nj6

 

My digital ARC came from the publisher, Crooked Lane Books, through NetGalley, with no expectation of a positive review.

 

 

Kevin R. Tipple ©2026

No comments: