Tuesday, October 20, 2026

Publication Day Review: The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2026, Editor Megan Abott, Series Editor Steph Cha


The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2026, Editor Megan Abbott, Series Editor Steph Cha, reprints twenty of their favorite short stories of the year. There are also thirty more tales listed in the honorable mention section to consider. This means you have a lot of good reading here. I won’t try to mention them all. What follows below are the several that really struck a chord with me for one reason or another.

 

“Smoke and Mirrors” by Charles John Harper originally appeared in an unspecified issue of Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine.  It features Private Investigator Darrow Nash, in Los Angeles, and quite the historical mystery tale. If you like a whodunit style read, this one is for you. I am not about to ruin it by saying more.

 

“Finding Jimmy Baldwin” by Cheryl A. Head originally appeared in the anthology, Crime Ink: Iconic: An Anthology of Crime Fiction Inspired by Queer Icons. It is June 1954 and Roy has shown up at the diner on schedule. Jimmy is a no show. That isn’t good news. The fact That Jimmy, full name James Arthur Baldwin, now has a missing person’s report according to the officer, a Sergeant Peterson, is worse news. Especially for Roy.

 

“The Corpse Collector” by David Morrell also appeared in an unspecified issue of Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine.  A dental hygienist needs a second job to make ends meet. One of her patients, a funeral director, suggested that she could collect the dead for him. Especially in the middle of the night. The pay would be really good and she agreed to do it on weekends. That has led to a lot of interesting pickups, and she will tell you about several of them, and then tell you about the big one last weekend.

 

“Small Things” by Wanda M. Morris previously appeared as an Amazon Original Story. Hannah Ferguson loves the shed out back. She does her art in it and hides her creativity in the small space. Her marriage is on a downhill slide. At least she still has her art and the freedom it can bring her.  

 

For Rosalie, With Love” by M. E. Proctor originally appeared in the anthology, Myopic Duplicity: Do the Ends Ever Justify the Means? The plan is, as it always has been since they first met. Do anything and everything for Rosalie.

 

“Mama” by Rob D. Smith originally appeared In Too Deep. Jimmy “Ton” Roy thought it was all clear to boost the white Corvette. He’s behind the wheel when the beautiful driver comes back for her purse. Jon’s plan to boost the cool car changes as does his future.

 

“Slow Ride” by Mark Thielman originally appeared in Chop Shop. The young guy  known as “Lil Meathead” swiped the Ford F-250 and got away with it. He did the work though the boss of the crew, Woody, fueled by meth and ego, will take much of the credit. Huey, the overall boss and the owner of the day time garage and night time chop shop did not really want another pickup truck. Here in Dallas so the truck won’t bring top dollar. But, there is a possibility of a really big payday. Lil Meathead  knows of a 2022 Bently set up for American driver. It has the steering wheel on the left, is purple, and has all the bells and whistles. Huey is interested. That means  soon Lil Meathead and Woody are dee in conversation while headed up the Dallas North Tollway to swipe the car.

 

The seven stories highlighted here are my personal favorites. No doubt your selections would probably be different. There isn’t a bad one in the bunch. The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2026 will provide you a lot of good reading and is well worth your time.

 


 

Amazon Associate Purchase Link: https://amzn.to/4spesnf

 

 

 

My digital ARC reading copy came from the publisher, Mariner Books, by way of NetGalley with no expectation of a positive review.

 

 

Kevin R. Tipple ©2026

No comments: