Sunday, May 10, 2026
Saturday, March 11, 2023
Scott's Take: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Illustrated Edition by J.K. Rowling Art by Jim Kay and Neil Packer
Harry Potter and
the Order of the Phoenix Illustrated Edition by J.K. Rowling features the art
of Jim Kay and Neil Packer. All previous four other volumes feature Jim Kay only
artist. However, in this book, he is sharing the artwork with Neil Packer as
Jim Kay is stepping down due to mental health concerns. If the series is
continued, there is a good chance that it won’t be as visually consistent as it
has been in the past due to the absence of Jim Kay.
The story is the same as the novel so Harry is dealing with the Ministry trying to take over Hogwarts and refusing to acknowledge that Voldemort is back.
Nothing is different book wise as far as I can tell. The art is excellent and highlights the visual differences between the movie version and the book version. Since the art depicts the book version, characters are not as attractive as their Hollywood version counterparts. Hagrid is more giant like and ugly while Severeus Snape is less of a pretty boy than the movies depicted him. Some parts are depicted more whimsically than the realistic style the movies preferred to go with.
There is a lot of illustrations for this type of book. While I would prefer more, I always want more illustrations in this series. I highly enjoyed seeing how scenes in the novel are visualized here in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix Illustrated Edition. I am hoping that the continue with the next book. I also hope that Jim Kay is able to get the help he needs.
My reading copy
came from the Vickery Park Branch of the Dallas Public Library System.
Scott A. Tipple ©2023
Saturday, December 26, 2020
Scott's Take: Batman: Last Knight on Earth by Scott Snyder and art by Greg Capullo
Batman:
Last Knight on Earth
by Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo is a DC Black Label title that is an adult orientated
tale and not for young kids or sensitive readers of any age. This graphic novel
is by Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo. This creative team created one of the most
well-regarded modern runs for a Batman series. They had an incredible decade
long run with Scott Snyder writing the stories and Greg Capullo doing the impressive
artwork. This book is billed as their last time working together on a Batman
graphic novel, so they really pulled out all the stops.
Batman wakes
up twenty years into the future in Arkham Asylum and quickly figures out things
are way different then he remembers. He manages to get outside of the Asylum
and ventures off into this broken new world to figure out what has happened to
the planet and humanity. His traveling companion, who tells a good portion of
the story himself, is Joker who is not all there literally or figuratively.
Being decapitated can really screwup your memories and Joker has gaps. Joker
was decapitated and had his still alive head stuck in a jar which was then
subsequently buried deep in the sand for two decades. Batman and the bodiless Joker
in a jar must faces various horrors to uncover the truth about this nightmarish
world. They will encounter various heroes and villains and see some things.
Batman:
Last Night on Earth
is a great book featuring amazing art. I highly recommend pretty much any book
by Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo working together because they do a spectacular
job when they combine their talents. This is a very good book, but it is meant
as the epic finish to their prior work. While it could be read by itself, the
read could be a bit confusing as it is meant for those readers who have been following
on the entire series. Because it is designed as their grand finale, the book
pretty much features every major hero and villain in the DC universe as well as
everyone who is important to Batman whether they are a hero or villain.
It is a great
read.
Batman: Last Night on Earth
Scott Snyder
https://www.dccomics.com/talent/scott-snyder
Greg Capullo
https://www.dccomics.com/talent/greg-capullo
DC Black Label
https://dc.fandom.com/wiki/Category:DC_Black_Label
April 2020
ISBN# 978-1-4012-9596-0
Hardback (also available in eBook format)
184 Pages
My reading copy came from the Timberglen Branch of the Dallas Public Library System.
Scott A.
Tipple ©2020



