Thursday, June 05, 2025
Do Some Damage: Interview: RyNyx Discusses Her Love of Mysteries and Her Dark Academia Standalone, ENIGMA
Sunday, November 21, 2021
Monday, November 08, 2021
Aubrey Nye Hamilton Reviews: A Limited Justice by Catriona King
Catriona King
is a medical doctor, originally from Belfast in Northern Ireland. She relocated
to London to work as a physician and trained as a medical forensics expert there,
assisting the Metropolitan Police with their cases. She returned to Belfast
where she now lives and writes the DCI Craig police procedural series. The
first book about Craig was published in 2012 by Crooked CAT Publishing. The
second edition was released in 2016 on Amazon’s independent publishing platform
CreateSpace. The 25th book in the series was issued recently in June
2021. The books are based in
Northern Ireland but often involve other parts of the UK and Europe.
A Limited
Justice
introduces Detective Chief Inspector Marc Craig of the Belfast Docklands
Coordinated Crime Unit and his team of homicide investigators, as well as
Craig’s lifelong friend Dr. John Winters, the lead medical examiner. The team
is tackling a bizarre homicide at a gasoline station, where the victim was
drenched with fuel but seems to have died from a blow to his head. The
instrument used to administer that blow is hard to identify and some of the
trace evidence is unusual. When some of the same elements show up at an apparent
mugging and drowning in Limavady, 60 miles northwest of Belfast, Craig’s team
realizes the two investigations will lead to the same person, despite the
differences in murder methods.
An excellent contemporary
procedural that emphasizes forensics, as might be expected considering the
author’s professional credentials. A thread about the killer runs in parallel
to the investigation. Normally I don’t like to know what the culprit is
thinking, it so seldom is edifying, but this murderer is not ordinary. At all. I
consider the freshness of the plot to be a high point of the story.
The single false note is the treatment of Detective Inspector Julia McNulty, lead for the Limavady homicide team. She is presented as difficult, egotistic, and defensive, disliked by her coworkers. Nonetheless she melts as soon as Craig looks at her. Really stereotypical and offensive treatment of a woman in a managerial role. A solid editor would have corrected this glaring fault in the story before it saw print. However, the story line is so original that I can recommend this debut of a long-running and potentially binge-worthy series, especially to fans of police procedurals.
·
Publisher: CreateSpace
Independent Publishing Platform; 2nd edition (May 31, 2016)
·
Language: English
·
Paperback: 286 pages
·
ISBN-10: 1533494509
·
ISBN-13: 978-1533494504
Aubrey Nye Hamilton ©2021
Aubrey Hamilton is a former librarian who works
on Federal It projects by day and reads mysteries at night.
Monday, November 01, 2021
Aubrey Nye Hamilton Reviews: Every Kind of Wicked by Lisa Black
Lisa Black writes two contemporary crime fiction
series, one about Theresa MacLean and one about Maggie Gardiner and Jack
Renner. Both MacLean and Gardiner are forensic scientists, the regular day
occupation of Black, whose real name is Elizabeth Becka Lansky. Maggie Gardiner teams
up with a homicide investigator named Jack Renner in the second series, set in
Cleveland. The third book in the series was shortlisted for the 2019 Sue
Grafton Award.
In the sixth
book Every Kind of Wicked (Kensington, 2020), Maggie is called to a deserted
cemetery to examine the site around a bloody corpse for clues amid falling
snow. At first glance it is a mugging gone wrong but when the medical examiner couldn’t
figure out what kind of weapon was used to kill the young man and when his
girlfriend vanishes as soon as she heard he was dead, the police know they have
a real mystery on their hands. An apparent victim of an overdose in another
part of town turns out to have ties to the first case, linking the two and
adding another level of complexity to what seemed initially to be a simple
investigation. Lots of local color about Cleveland add depth to the story.
The creatively
construed plot is a well thought out tale of white collar crime, with plenty of
surprises and misdirection. It is hard to say much about it without giving away
some key points. Multiple story lines come together neatly in an intricate
police procedural that features forensic investigative detail and analysis.
On the other
hand, I have to wonder why anyone who can fashion a devious narrative like this
one would dream up a character like Jack Renner, whose back story challenges
credulity from the outset. And yes, I understand this is the sixth book in
which he’s appeared. The first two or three chapters of this book focused on
Maggie’s agita over her dealings with Jack, and I nearly put it down. I read
crime fiction for the crime and the investigation, not the relationships.
I expect the mixed reviews from the professional reviewing sources reflect this dichotomy of great plot and unbelievable characters: Kirkus gave it a starred review and Publishers Weekly said it is so-so. Recommended for fans of forensic medical thrillers and police procedurals with the caveat that they will have to look past some questionable characterization.
·
Publisher: Kensington (August
25, 2020)
·
Language: English
·
Hardcover: 336 pages
·
ISBN-10: 1496722388
· ISBN-13: 978-1496722386
Aubrey Nye Hamilton ©2021
Aubrey Hamilton is a former librarian who works
on Federal It projects by day and reads mysteries at night.


