Lesa's Book Critiques: The Story of Classic Crime in 100 Books by Martin Edwards
Tuesday, November 25, 2025
Monday, September 22, 2025
Aubrey Nye Hamilton Reviews: 6:40 to Montreal by Eva Jurczyk
Eva Jurczyk is a librarian
performing collection development for University of Toronto Libraries by day
and an author by night. She’s published two novels, the third is forthcoming
this fall.
6:40 to Montreal (Poisoned Pen Press, 2025) is
clearly a nod to Christie’s Murder on the Orient Express, including the
main character’s name. Agatha lives in Toronto, she is married to Teddy, a
restaurant manager, and they have a son named Freddie. Agatha is an aspiring
writer with multiple rejection slips to show for it. A couple of years ago,
strictly as a lark, she wrote a fluffy murder mystery about a yoga instructor
and would-be media influencer modeled on a young woman who had worked in her
husband’s restaurants for several years. The book became a runaway hit, to
Agatha’s surprise. The yoga instructor, whom Agatha thought would not see the
book, recognized herself in the story and boiled over with rage, threatening Agatha
with violence.
In addition to her unexpected
status of bestselling author, Agatha was also diagnosed with advanced stage melanoma.
She’s undergone surgery and is taking medication to reduce the likelihood of a
recurrence. She is overwhelmed with grief at the thought of not living to see
her son grow up and she’s been unable to do much of anything, include write another
bestseller.
To cheer her up and give her
time to write, Teddy gives her a round-trip train ticket to Montreal. Agatha
arrives at the station early despite the building snowstorm, takes her seat,
and soon after an older man demands that she give him her place. The car is
nearly empty and she moves across the aisle.
The snowstorm turns into a
furious blizzard; the train slows and eventually stops. About that time they
notice the older man who took Agatha’s seat is dead. Murdered, the group
realizes.
The loss of power caused the wifi
connection to vanish, the doors to lock, and the internal telephone to close
down. Agatha has plenty of time to wonder if she is supposed to be dead instead
of the man who took her place.
Another death, a passenger in
diabetic coma, a missing attendant, and a small group of passengers who grow
increasingly frantic. There’s a twist at the end that could be interpreted in
more than one way.
Reviews on GoodReads are
mixed. Some readers loved it, some disliked it, a few didn’t know what to think
about it. I find myself in the latter camp, mostly because of a gap or two in
the plot, the ambiguous final surprise, and Agatha’s reaction to it.
·
Publisher:
Poisoned Pen Press
·
Publication
date: October 28, 2025
·
Language:
English
·
Print
length: 352 pages
·
ISBN-10:
1464244464
·
ISBN-13:
978-1464244469
Amazon Associate Purchase Link: https://amzn.to/4gznnMP
Aubrey Nye Hamilton ©2025
Aubrey Hamilton is a former librarian who works on Federal
It projects by day and reads mysteries at night.
Friday, May 16, 2025
FFB Review-- Aubrey Nye Hamilton Reviews: The Coffin Trail by Martin Edwards
From the archive….
The Coffin Trail by Martin Edwards (Poisoned Pen Press,
October 2004) is the first book in the author’s Lake District mystery series,
which now has seven titles. He has also written eight mysteries featuring
lawyer Harry Devlin. Edwards is perhaps better known as a crime fiction critic
and anthologist, which is unfortunate, because his mysteries are fine reads.
Daniel Kind, an Oxford historian, visits a childhood
vacation spot in England’s scenic Lake District with his new lover Miranda,
where they impulsively buy a run-down home and decide to leave their urban
lives to start over. Part of his interest in the village is in clearing the
name of a local youth he’d been friends with during the long-ago holiday and
who since then had been unofficially blamed for the gruesome murder of a
tourist. About the same time DCI Hannah Scarlett of the local police force is assigned
to clear up a number of cold cases, including this one. DCI Scarlett carries
out her official investigation in parallel with Kind’s informal questioning of
the long-time residents, both of which upset a lot of people for different
reasons. They each gather essential clues that eventually they jointly assemble
into a resolution that has a further twist at the very end.
Kind serves as tour guide to Miranda, in between wrangling
with the local contractors they have hired to renovate the house, which allows
the story to showcase the geographical features of the Lake District. Setting is sometimes referred to as an
additional character in a story; in this one the rich descriptions of the region’s
hills and landmarks nearly elbow everyone else off the page.
This
book was nominated for the Theakston Old
Peculier Crime Writing Festival’s prize for
best British crime novel of 2006.
- Series: Lake District Mysteries
- Hardcover: 312 pages
- Publisher: Poisoned Pen Press; First Edition
(October 1, 2004)
- ISBN-10: 1590581296
- ISBN-13: 978-1590581292
Amazon Associate Purchase Link: https://amzn.to/3GYdbzS
Aubrey Hamilton © 2017, 2025
Aubrey Hamilton is a former librarian who works on Federal
IT projects by day and reads mysteries at night.
Monday, August 12, 2024
Saturday, March 23, 2024
Wednesday, November 15, 2023
Lesa's Book Critiques: HANGING THE DEVIL BY TIM MALEENY
Monday, November 13, 2023
Aubrey Nye Hamilton Reviews: Hanging the Devil by Tim Maleeny
Hanging the
Devil
(Poisoned Pen Press, November 2023) is the fifth book about private
investigator Cape Weather which Tim Maleeny has been leisurely producing over a
span of several years. The first volume of this fine series was published in
2007 and we’re only getting #5 some 16 years later. Some of us wish he could
write a bit faster. On the other hand, we have plenty of time to savor each
title about Weathers and his sidekick Sally Mei, trained by the Triad as an
assassin and now watching over San Francisco’s Chinatown.
Mei is just
the right person for Grace, an eleven-year-old girl in trouble, to find. Grace
was in the Asian Art Museum, where her uncle was security guard, when a
helicopter crashed into one of the plate glass windows in an attempted robbery.
The crash killed the pilot and Grace’s uncle but the robbers swept through the
museum anyway and took a valuable Buddha before the police arrived. They saw
Grace and gave chase but she escaped and Sally hid her in her secure loft
apartment. Sally views any crime in Chinatown as a personal affront, and she
enlists Weathers to assist her in identifying the lowlifes who had the impudence
to raid the museum. The scene shifts periodically to Hong Kong, where Grace’s
father Wen is imprisoned for his incorrect political views and he discovers some
chilling medical experiments underway in the jail.
The plot
threads link seamlessly across the major elements down to the final words in
each chapter beginning the next one. Very slick. The action is nonstop and the points
of view are complex, as the crime draws together Chinese mobsters, Russian
gangsters, an Interpol agent, and the local police, along with Grace, Weathers,
and Mei. The Chinatown setting is rife with realistic detail, reflecting Maleeny’s
long association with the area. Amusing dialogue and polished writing top off a
very good read. Highly recommended.
Starred
review from Library Journal and LJ’’s September Mystery Pick of
the Month.
(Get it here as things at Amazon are not working quite right. KRT)
·
Publisher: Poisoned Pen Press (November
14, 2023)
·
Language: English
·
Paperback: 416 pages
·
ISBN-10: 172827916X
·
ISBN-13: 978-1728279169
Aubrey Nye Hamilton ©2023
Aubrey Hamilton is a former librarian who works on Federal It projects by day and reads mysteries at night.
Friday, August 19, 2022
Lesa's Book Critiques: WINNERS AND A COMPLETE SERIES GIVEAWAY
Saturday, August 06, 2022
Thursday, March 31, 2022
Review: No Accident: A Posadas County Mystery by Steven F. Havill
No Accident: A Posadas County Mystery
by Steven F. Havill opens with Undersheriff Estelle Reyes-Guzman dealing with
the aftermath of a brutal bar fight at the Broken Spur Saloon. Johnny Rabke is
drunk and bleeding heavily, a tourist family of four is traumatized, and the
unconscious combatant on the floor is Pablo Ramirez. He had pulled out a knife
after exchanging insults, Johnny Rabke had swung a pool cue at least once, and had
also ended the fight by throwing a billiard ball and nailing Ramirez in the
right side of his head.
That fight and the charges and everything around all
that becomes secondary as does life in Posadas when she gets a midnight call
from her son, Francisco. Her first thought is that something has happened to
her grandson but she can hear him in the background and so she knows he is
okay. Instead, the call is about her other son, Carlos, and his wife, Tasha.
Francisco explains that Carlos and Tasha were on
their tandem bike out in California and were run down. Both have suffered
series injuries and are in the Temerly Trauma Treatment Center in Briones,
California. Tasha is doing a little bit better than Carlos who is still in
surgery and in a very bad way. Francisco and his family are headed to the
airport in New York to board their private jet. They plan to fly to Posadas and
pick up mom and dad, Estelle and her husband, Dr. Francis Guzman, and go to California
to be there for Carlos and Tasha.
Before long the entire group is on the ground in
California. As it happens, Eddie Mitchell is a captain with the Briones Police
Department and supervising the investigation as it is clear that this was no
simple hit and run. This was definitely attempted murder. Not only were they
run over once, the driver backed up and hit them a second time. Not only does
he want Estelle and the family to be fully supported as they await to see if
Carlos survives his life-threatening injuries, Mitchell is determined to find
the guilty party or parties and get them off the street and in custody.
To do that, he is going to walk a tightrope as he
wants Estelle’s help, but she has no authority in California. He also knows how
she is and does not want her independently pursuing her own lines of inquiry or
doing anything that could give a defense lawyer ammunition at trial. Things get
more complicated quickly as a body is found that could be tied into the case.
What follows is a complicated read that shifts back
and forth from the hospital and the patients to the actual investigation of the
crime. While there are the occasional brief contacts with the folks back home,
the vast majority of the novel takes place out in California. Along the way, the
author spends considerable time on family dynamics, the predatory behavior of
some men towards women, and other issues as the investigation moves forward on
multiple fronts. It is not until the last chapter and the final eight pages
that the initial event that started the book is resolved.
Overall, while not the best read in this long
running series, No Accident: A Posadas County Mystery was
entertaining and enjoyable. Though the tale was interesting, this reader missed
the New Mexico setting which is often so effectively used a character in its own
right. This reader was also frequently reminded of the idea that it is good to
have friends, but having plenty of money to deal with emergencies helps too. So
too does having your own doctor in the family.
My print reading copy came by way of Aubrey Nye Hamilton to sent it to me after she had read it. Yet another way Aubrey does wonderful things for me and this blog. Thank you, Aubrey. As always.
Kevin R. Tipple ©2022
Monday, August 24, 2020
Aubrey Hamilton Reviews: Nantucket Sawbuck by Steven Axelrod
Monday, August 12, 2019
Aubrey Hamilton Reviews: Fogland Point by Doug Burgess
Friday, January 18, 2019
Sunday, September 30, 2018
Wednesday, September 05, 2018
Monday, August 06, 2018
Thursday, June 21, 2018
Tuesday, February 06, 2018
Monday, January 01, 2018
Aubrey Hamilton Reviews: A Few Right-Thinking Men by Sulari Gentill
Aubrey Hamilton © 2018
Monday, May 15, 2017
Aubrey Hamilton Reviews: The Coffin Trail by Martin Edwards
- Series: Lake District Mysteries
- Hardcover: 312 pages
- Publisher: Poisoned Pen Press; First Edition edition (October 1, 2004)
- ISBN-10: 1590581296
- ISBN-13: 978-1590581292










